2024 Treats of the Month Club

Complete the form at the bottom of the page join the 2024 Treats of the Month Club

Allergy Statement

All items are made in a fully licensed home kitchen. Menu items contain gluten/wheat, dairy, and eggs and may contain or come into contact with soy, peanuts, or tree nuts. While I take the necessary precautions to prevent cross-contamination, I am not a gluten-free, dairy-free, nut-free kitchen.
I cannot make allergy-friendly boxes. Please skip a month if you’re allergic to any of the ingredients

What You Get:

  • A box of desserts each month that are only available to the club members.

  • Twice the points with the loyalty program at markets and pop-ups.

How does it work?

  1. Read the menus for each month

  2. Select your box size:

    • Mini Boxes - $30

      • 2 cake balls or 1 cakesicle

      • 2 single cookies

      • 1 cookie sandwich or donut

      • 1 bar

      • A quarter of a bundt cake or half of a loaf of bread/cake

    • Small Boxes - $50

      • 4 cake balls or 2 cakesicles

      • 4 single cookies

      • 2 cookie sandwiches or donuts

      • 2 bars

      • Half of a bundt cake or a whole loaf bread/cake

    • Large Boxes - $85

      • 8 cake balls or 4 cakesicles

      • 8 single cookies

      • 4 cookie sandwiches or donuts

      • 4 bars

      • Half of a bundt cake or a whole loaf bread/cake

    • Jumbo Boxes - $155

      • 12 cake balls or 6 cakesicles

      • 12 single cookies

      • 8 cookie sandwiches or donuts

      • 8 bars

      • A whole bundt cake or 2 whole loaves of bread/cake

  3. Fill out the form at the bottom of the page to sign up for the club membership(s).

    • You can choose a full-year club membership or specific months.

      • You must choose a minimum of 3 months to join

  4. That’s it! I will send the invoice on the 1st of each month.

    • You must pay by the 3rd of each month to renew your club membership. If I do not receive a payment or response by the 5th of the month, your membership will be canceled for that month.

    • You can get 10% off if you prepay for the entire year.

      • Payments will be due by January 10th or within a week of signing up if you become a member after January 10, 2024.

The Details

Order this box of exclusive treats for yourself, share it with loved ones, or find more ways to share the goodness! These boxes make great gifts for those with a sweet tooth and are a tasty way to say “thank you” to your employees at work. The options for sharing are endless when you join the Treats of the Month Club!

  • Pickup will be in Kettering, Ohio on Thursdays and Fridays, Saturdays.

    • The pickup address will be sent in your pickup confirmation email each month

  • If the month you want is not on the form, either the signup date has passed or that month is full.

    • Registration closes on the 1st of each month, so you must register for the month before the 1st.

  • If you want to cancel the club membership, please email me to let me know before the 1st of the month.

  • I will add you to a newsletter that is sent out on the 1st.

    • Please do NOT unsubscribe from this as it will contain all the pick-up information and any menu changes.

  • If you are not able to pick up your box after payment, please contact me for the refund/credit options.

    • I cannot make the box another day or week, so keep this in mind when you’re signing up.

  • The items in the specialty boxes are subject to change. Final menus will be listed in the monthly newsletter each month.

  • The “No Ghosting” Policy

    • If you receive an invoice, then do not pay the invoice OR email me to cancel for that month, you will lose your spot in the Treats of the Month Club and will be banned from joining in the future. Please be respectful of my time and let me know if you want to cancel so I’m not spending time following up.

Treats of the Month Club Boxes for 2024

Items in these boxes are exclusive to the members and cannot be purchased outside of the memberships.

January - Parks & Recreation
(REGISTRATION CLOSED)

“There has never been a sadness that can’t be cured by breakfast food.”—Ron Swanson
Pickup: January 18-20

  • Cones of Dunshire Cake Balls

    • Tom may have said that your favorite kind of cake can’t be birthday cake, but that won’t stop us from making these birthday cake balls with edible cones on top, ala the Cones of Dunshire game

  • Emergency S’mores Rations Cookies

    • Leslie won’t need to dip into her stash for these!

  • Treat Yo Self Mimosa Donuts

    • Treat yo self 2024 with these boozy donuts that even Donna and Tom would approve of

  • Bourbon Bacon Brownies

    • These might even make Ron Swanson crack a smile

  • Waffle Bundt Cake with Maple Glaze

    • There are no foods finer than from JJ’s diner, but this bundt cake comes close to his waffles.

February - Sweet & Savory
(REGISTRATION CLOSED)

Try new goodies for your sweet tooth and savory side with this unique blend of baked goods
Pickup: February 22-24

  • Chili Chocolate Truffles

  • Cheddar Cheese Crinkle Cookies

  • Sesame Tahini Cookies with Chocolate Ganache

  • Jalapeno Cheddar Cornbread

  • Milk Chocolate Rye Bread

March - Taylor Swift
(REGISTRATION CLOSED)

Relive some of Taylor’s classic eras with this box. I guarantee you will remember it all too well…
Pickup: March 21-23

  • Loving him was Red velvet cakesicles

    • Complete with autumn leaves falling down like pieces into place

  • Chai Cookies

    • Taylor’s favorite recipe, courtesy of her Tumblr days

  • I Just Wanna Stay in that Lavender Haze with my London Boy Cookie Sandwiches

    • Lavender Earl Grey cookie sandwiches with a caramel frosting

  • Last Kiss Blondies

    • Classic blondies with mini Hershey’s kisses

  • Reputation Bundt Cake

    • Black cocoa bundt cake with black vanilla drizzle and black and silver sprinkles

April - Candyland
(REGISTRATION CLOSED)

Revisit your childhood classic by eating your way through the iconic game.
Pickup: April 18-20

  • Candy Castle Cake Balls

    • Confetti cake balls dipped like ice cream in a mini ice cream cone

  • Mama Ginger Tree’s Gingersnaps

  • Mr. Mint’s Peppermint Chocolate Cookie Sandwiches

  • Grandma Nutt’s Peanut Brittle Blondies

    • Contains peanuts

  • Strawberry Marbled Bundt Cake

  • Bonus: Lord Licorice’s Bitter Chocolate Bats

May - Vintage Bakes

Take a tour of bakes past with this timeless box.
Pickup: May 16-18

  • Brownstone Front Cake Cake Balls

    • Caramel-y cake with a sweet frosting

  • Cowboy Cookies

    • An amped-up chocolate chip oatmeal cookie

  • Amish Sugar Cookies with Brown Sugar Frosting

  • Hello Dolly Bars

    • A crunchy graham cracker base topped with a mix of pecans, chocolate chips, and coconut flakes. A pour of sweetened condensed milk transforms them into delectable caramelized bars during baking.

    • Contains pecans and coconut

  • Black Walnut Caramel Loaf Cake

    • Contains walnuts

The Treats of the Month Club will be on a summer break for June, July, and August.

Please come visit Gem City Bakehouse at markets over these months!

September - The Magical Wizarding World

Run to platform 9 ¾ and jump on the Hogwarts Express for a chance to get this magical box.
Pickup: September 12-14

  • Golden Snitch Cakesicles

    • Pumpkin cake

  • Butterbeer No Bake Cookies

  • Butterbeer Cookie Sandwiches

  • Treacle Tart Bars

  • Hogwarts Elves’ Chocolate Gateau

  • Bonus: Chocolate Frogs

October - This is Halloween

Spooky scary skeletons and ghouls all love the tricks and treats in this month’s box.
Pickup: October 17-19

  • Mummy Cake Balls

    • Coffee Toffee Cake

  • Pumpkin Cookies w/Spice Glaze

  • Chocolate Monster Donuts

  • Skulls

    • Red Velvet Brownies with White Glaze

  • Apple Cider Donut Pound Cake

November - Thankful for Fall Flavors

This box is full of the warm and comforting flavors we love this time of year.
Pickup: November 25-27

  • Sweet Potato Cake Balls

  • Bourbon-Caramel Cookies

  • Cinnamon Roll Donuts

  • Pumpkin Brownies

  • Pumpkin Donut Bundt Cake

December - The Most Wonderful Desserts of the Year

Put on your holiday jammies and your favorite movie while you indulge in the final box of 2024!
Pickup: December 20-23

  • Buckeyes

    • Contains peanuts

  • Ginger Cookies

  • Chocolate Cookie Sandwich with Mint Frosting

  • White Chocolate Brownies with Dark Chocolate Swirl

  • Gingerbread Streusel Bundt Cake

Introducing: Add-Ons

You’ve asked and we’re finally answering with a resounding “Yes!”

You’ll have the option to add on more of any items in your box if you want more of a specific item.

You cannot remove items from the boxes - the base for each size cannot be changed.

You can either add the items you want more of and each quantity on the form below or email me before the 3rd of each month to get any items added to your box. Please wait to pay your invoice if you’re adding on at the start of the month so I can add your extras to your invoice.

The add-ons will be market price:

Cake Balls - $2.00 each

Cakesicles - $7.00 each

Single Cookies - $1.25 each

Cookie Sandwiches - $4.50 each

Bars - $5.50 each

Donuts - $3.00 each

Bundt Cake (Half) - 15.00 each

Bundt Cake (Quarter) - $8.00 each

Loaves (Full) - $15.00 each

Loaves (Half) - $8.00 each

Sign up to become a 2024 member of the Treats of the Month Club!

You will not be taken to a payment page. I will confirm your membership within 5 business days.

You must select a minimum of 3 months to become a member. Any forms with less than 3 months selected will not be confirmed.